| Color | Option | Source | Common US label names | EU number |
|---|
| Red, pink | Beet colors | Red beets | beet juice, beet powder, vegetable juice (color) | E162 (beetroot red) |
| Red, purple | Anthocyanins | Purple carrot, red cabbage, grape skins, berries | fruit juice, vegetable juice, grape skin extract | E163 |
| Red | Carmine, cochineal extract | Cochineal insects | carmine, cochineal extract | E120 |
| Orange-red | Paprika extract | Capsicum peppers | paprika, paprika extract, paprika oleoresin | E160c |
| Yellow-orange | Annatto | Annatto (achiote) seeds | annatto, annatto extract | E160b |
| Yellow-orange | Beta-carotene | Algae, fungi, plants, or synthetic | beta-carotene | E160a |
| Yellow | Turmeric | Turmeric root | turmeric, turmeric oleoresin, "spice and coloring" | E100 (curcumin) |
| Blue, green | Spirulina extract | Spirulina (Arthrospira) | spirulina extract | None (colouring food) |
| Blue, purple | Butterfly pea flower extract | Clitoria ternatea flowers | butterfly pea flower extract | None |
| Blue | Gardenia (genipin) blue | Gardenia fruit plus soy protein | gardenia blue | None |
| Blue | Galdieria extract blue | Galdieria sulphuraria red algae | galdieria extract blue | None |
| White | Calcium phosphate | Mineral, synthetically prepared | calcium phosphate | Not an EU color (E341 has other uses) |
| Brown | Caramel color | Heated sugars | caramel color | E150a, E150b, E150c, E150d |
| Black | Vegetable carbon | Charred plant material | Not permitted in US foods | E153 |
Reds and pinks
Beet juice and dehydrated beet powder have been permitted for decades. They give a bright pink-red but fade with heat, so they suit yogurt, drinks, and frostings better than baked goods. Anthocyanins from purple carrot, red cabbage, and grape skins are red in acidic foods and drift toward purple and blue as acidity drops.
Carmine is the performance benchmark for natural red because it holds up to baking and long shelf lives, but it comes from insects. Our carmine guide lists real products that use it.
Oranges and yellows
This is the easiest part of the spectrum to replace. Paprika extract, annatto, and beta-carotene cover yellow to red-orange, and we compare them side by side in annatto vs paprika extract vs beta-carotene. Turmeric gives a vivid lemon yellow but is sensitive to light. Under 21 CFR 101.22, paprika and turmeric may be declared as "spice and coloring" unless they are listed by name, which can make them easy to miss.
Blues: the hardest color to replace
Natural blue has always been the bottleneck. Spirulina extract owes its color to phycocyanin, a protein that a review in PMC found is most stable around pH 5.5 to 6.0 and below about 45°C, and that turns greenish in acidic conditions. That is a poor match for tart sodas and baked cereal.
Butterfly pea flower extract is anthocyanin-based, so its shade shifts with acidity. The FDA describes it as giving "bright blues, intense purple, and natural greens." Gardenia blue holds up well to light and pH changes but is sensitive to heat above about 80°C, according to a review of natural and synthetic blue dyes. Galdieria extract blue is phycocyanin from a red alga that lives in hot, acidic springs, and a 2021 study found it kept its color better than spirulina phycocyanin when heated.
Food scientists told FoodNavigator that blue remains the toughest synthetic dye to replace, with natural sources tending toward softer aqua or teal shades. Green inherits the problem because it is usually blue plus yellow. Sodium copper chlorophyllin, a green made from chlorophyll, is approved in the US only for citrus-based dry beverage mixes.
Whites, browns and blacks
Calcium phosphate, approved in 2025, is a white option for ready-to-eat chicken products, white candy melts, doughnut sugar, and sugar for coated candies. Caramel color supplies most of the brown in colas, sauces, and baked goods. Vegetable carbon gives the jet black seen in European charcoal buns and ice cream, but it is not an approved food color in the US.