Products are reformulating on different timelines. This means that a product you bought last year may have a different formulation today, and a product that still contains FD&C dyes may be reformulated by next year.
A few practical steps for navigating this period:
Check the ingredient list, not the front of pack. A product marketed as "made with real fruit" or featuring nature imagery may still contain synthetic dyes. The ingredient list is the only reliable source. Certified dyes can appear as FD&C Red No. 40, Red 40, Red 40 Lake, Yellow 5, Blue 1, and so on. Our guide to Red 40, Yellow 5, and the other dyes being phased out lists the common label names.
Know what "no artificial colors" means now. Since February 5, 2026, the FDA allows a "no artificial colors" claim on foods that contain no petroleum-based certified colors, even if they contain colors from natural sources. A product with that claim may still contain carmine, annatto, or other natural dyes that matter for people with specific sensitivities. Our explainer on the new meaning of "no artificial colors" goes deeper.
Expect Red 3 on some shelves after January 15, 2027. The deadline applies to when a food is made, so older stock can remain for sale. If you are avoiding Red 3, keep checking labels on candy, frosting, frozen desserts, and baked goods into 2027.
Watch for carmine and annatto in reformulated products. These are among the most common replacements for Red 40 and Yellow 6, respectively. If you have shellfish allergies, are vegan, or have experienced reactions to natural colorings, carmine and annatto are worth checking explicitly.
Look for the label change itself. Some brands will explicitly note "new recipe" or "now made with natural colors" on reformulated products. Others will simply update the ingredient list without any front-of-pack notice.